Car Key Replacement: Auto Locksmith or Dealership?

admin • March 19, 2022

Being locked out of your car by accident or losing your car keys is never fun. There are several ways you can get back into your car when you’re locked out, but not all of them are easy. If you’re lucky, you might have a family member or friend who is kind enough to fetch that extra key for you. If you aren’t so fortunate and don’t have a spare key, however, you’ll probably have to make a service call or two before you can get back on with your day.


In this case, you have two options. You can call a dealership or an auto locksmith. Although both options have similar outcomes, their experiences are not quite the same. Choosing a dealer in this scenario can be a headache for various reasons, so let’s take a look at why the best option is to call a locksmith.

Who’s Faster When Locked Out?

In most cases, your dealership will be able to give you a replacement key if you’ve locked your own set in your car. However, they don’t have any other means of getting into the vehicle, so if you’re in a rush and aren’t anywhere near your dealership, this isn’t ideal. An auto locksmith, however, will be able to open your car door lock without the need for a new key, so if you want to get moving again and fast, locksmiths are the best choice, especially in an emergency.


If you’ve ever used roadside assistance before, you’ll know dealerships are the last place they will call if you’ve locked your keys in your vehicle. Dealerships simply aren’t equipped to handle the problem promptly, so you are better off contacting an auto locksmith for the quickest solution.

What's The Cheaper Option?

The best way to save money when replacing your vehicle’s key is to choose an auto locksmith rather than a dealership. This is because the overheads at dealerships tend to be higher than that of mobile businesses. What’s more, auto locksmiths have all the equipment they need to hand to get you back in your car or to cut a replacement key – dealerships may have to order a replacement, which could take days, weeks, or even months.

What's The Most Convenient Solution?

Specialisation is the fundamental difference between an auto locksmith and a dealership. Car dealerships are multi-purpose businesses, so even though they can unlock your door, that’s not their primary function. The locksmith business model focuses on making things as simple and convenient for clients as possible. The wait will be shorter, and you won’t need to book an appointment or wait in a dealership waiting room. Getting a temporary key won’t require a ride to the dealership either. Instead, all you have to do is sit with your vehicle until assistance comes to you.


In the end, the choice is yours. But if you want more convenience, lower prices and less hassle, you should contact a locksmith.

Close-up of a Locksmith — All Pro Locksmiths In Port Macquarie, NSW
By All Pro Locksmiths March 19, 2026
Can a locksmith unlock any car? Learn how modern vehicle security works, what locksmiths can access, and how safe, professional unlocking methods are used.
A Person Uses a Thin Metal Tool — All Pro Locksmiths In Port Macquarie, NSW
March 19, 2026
Learn the difference between transponder and regular car keys and when to call an auto locksmith in Port Macquarie. Get expert advice today.
Hand Holding Two Car Keys — All Pro Locksmiths In Port Macquarie, NSW
By All Pro Locksmiths January 8, 2026
Learn the difference between transponder and regular car keys and when to call an auto locksmith in Port Macquarie. Get expert advice today.
Hand Holding Two Audi Car Keys — All Pro Locksmiths In Port Macquarie, NSW
By All Pro Locksmiths December 2, 2025
Keep your car secure by knowing why a spare key matters and how an auto locksmith in Port Macquarie can help—read the blog today.
Hand Holding Car Keys Near a Beige Car Door — All Pro Locksmiths In Port Macquarie, NSW
By All Pro Locksmiths October 24, 2025
Avoid common mistakes when replacing lost car keys with expert car key cutting in Port Macquarie and trusted auto locksmith services.
Hand Holding Two Car Keys — All Pro Locksmiths In Port Macquarie, NSW
By All Pro Locksmiths September 10, 2025
Need a car locksmith in Port Macquarie? Call our emergency car locksmith service for fast help when locked out. Get expert assistance today.
Hand Holding Two Car Keys — All Pro Locksmiths In Port Macquarie, NSW
By All Pro Locksmiths August 8, 2025
Locked out in Port Macquarie? Discover why a local car locksmith is your fastest, smartest option. Learn more and get help when you need it most!
Hand holding car keys in front of a black Land Rover logo on a vehicle. — All Pro Locksmiths In Port Macquarie, NSW
By All Pro Locksmiths August 6, 2025
Locked out or lost your keys? Discover 8 key reasons to call a car locksmith Port Macquarie. Get expert help fast—read now.
Man Wearing Sunglasses Sits in a Black Sports Car — All Pro Locksmiths In Port Macquarie, NSW
By All Pro Locksmiths July 29, 2025
Discover when to call an emergency car locksmith. Learn about common situations and how to ensure your vehicle is secure and accessible again. Read more!
Man in Blue Overalls Picking a Lock on a Red Car Door — All Pro Locksmiths In Port Macquarie, NSW
By All Pro Locksmiths July 3, 2025
Prevent car lockouts with 8 simple tips. Trust our auto locksmith Port Macquarie for quick and reliable car lockout service. Stay secure today!
Show More